Reward the Team, Lose the Stars. Reward the Stars, Lose the Team. Now What?
A debate breaks out among leaders. The team just shipped something significant. Someone suggests giving "champion points" to the person who drove it. Someone else pushes back — "It was a team effort. Reward the whole team." A third person raises the obvious: "If we reward everyone equally, what's the incentive to go above and beyond?"
I've been in this room. It was equal parts funny and frustrating — everyone had a strong opinion, everyone had a good argument, and nobody was wrong. That's the problem.
This isn't a values debate. It's a design problem.